RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
Does wheel balance affect rolling resistence ?
I never really gave wheel balancing much thought before and using plastic wheels there wasn't much I could do about it anyway, but seeing as I have
these new ATV rims (hoping not to come across as smug).. I thought I'd try to get them balanced at my local tyre depot only to be told that their
machine won't fit my rims. So I bought a box of self adhesive weights online.
Without the aid of a computerised machine I've had to balance the wheel by hand which I did by first finding the inherently heavy section in the tyre,
spinning up the wheel, adding weights and then spin spun and span over and over until finally having the wheel come to rest at random, not in the same
place each time.
Its a slow process by hand and I've only managed one wheel tonight. The buggy was carefully levelled before I started and brand new bearings used. A
total counterweight of 90g or 3.1 ounces were required for the first wheel using 18 x 5g segments. That's quite a weight to be out of sync. I suppose
it might be down to the fact that the rim is only 8" compared to the 21" tyre. I'll do the rest tomorrow.
I feel that now at least I have one perfectly balanced wheel. The wheel is noticeably spinning for longer too which is a good sign. I'll probably not
notice any difference in the bug but I'm curious to find out.
Now that I'm having these rims balanced it got me thinking. It seems plausible to me that a set of unbalanced wheels would have an effect on bearing
wear and rolling resistance. I'm I right ?
Is uneven tyre weight just a bigfoot / BR problem or do discs suffer to some degree too, could we all benefit from balanced wheels, especially those
looking for that slight edge in racing or new speed records or could the effect of all this be so small as to make any difference at all ?
...and if anyone of you suspect that I may have just invented a whole new thread of questions just so I can show you my new stick on weights and what
a marvelous job I've done with them, then well!! That's just outrageous.
|
|
PHREERIDER
Posting Freak
Posts: 5781
Registered: 13-2-2008
Location: SC
Member Is Offline
Mood: chilled....but ready to SAIL!
|
|
rolling resistance no, but vibration and wheel contact with surface yes, it definitely gonna tighten things up and smooth out high speed runs for
more secure fee!. grass maybe not as noticeable. a guess would be around 30+ mph some vibe (more like "hum") through seat or pegs might be present
with really out of balance stuff.
|
|
BeamerBob
Posting Freak
Posts: 8308
Registered: 11-5-2007
Location: Down on the bayou
Member Is Offline
|
|
I agree it might remove traction robbing unweighting of the tire from the ground. I'm not sure about bearing life. Those really are some sexy
wheels!
Coastal Wind Sports Team Rider
Landsegler Disc wheels
PTW Hero Buggy - XXtreme ApeXX Buggy US 88 - Libre Hardcore
IvanpahBuggyExpo.com
Youtube link
Bob Muse
HQ Montana X 8m, Montana IX 12m, HQ Ignition LEI 5m,
PL Phantom 12m, 15m, Big Blu 24m+, Synergy 10m, Venom 10m, 13m , Phantom II 12m Vapors 3.8, 5.4, Crosskite Sonic 7m, PKD Combat 10.3m
Uturn Butane 2.5m PKD Buster 3m Genetrix Hydra 7m Ozone Yakuza GT 14m
|
|
abkayak
Posting Freak
Posts: 2272
Registered: 7-1-2012
Location: a.b. NY
Member Is Offline
Mood: loving life and becoming wise in simplicity
|
|
i thought everyone running high speed or interested in records was getting their tires bubble balanced manually and playing w/ weights??you may be
breaking ground w/ fatties..and it does look marvelous
US-31...Cquad set/ 2.5 Bullet/ 2.6 Viper/ 2.9m Reactor/ 2- 3.5m Bullet/ 3.6 Beamer/ 4m Buster/ 4m Toxic/ 4m Ikon dp/ 4.5 Bullet/ 4.9m Blade/ 5.6
Twister/ 6.6m Blade/ 7.5 Apex/ 9m Fuel/ Phantom I 9,12,15,18/ 2 Flexibugs/ PL Big Foot/ landboards
|
|
RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
Thanks Phree and BB. I'll never be able to test my theory scientifically and any improvements I might feel or see could be contributed to a placebo
effect but the wheels do at least spin smoother and slowly roll to a stop without rotating back the other way as they used to. All I need now is some
wind to ride and test. I've spent too long in the garage tweaking.
Actually, I just thought of something that I could test. I could leave one wheel unbalanced and see how long the new bearings last against the
balanced wheel. It may take a while but a worthwhile cause I think. Mmmmmm
|
|
RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
Quote: Originally posted by abkayak | i thought everyone running high speed or interested in records was getting their tires bubble balanced manually and playing w/ weights??you may be
breaking ground w/ fatties..and it does look marvelous |
By the way, I hope you don't think I'm fishing for more compliments..... am I that transparent! hehe
I've not come across the subject of balanced wheels before. I should have done a search and will do later but it did get me thinking and its got me
interested. Thanks dude.
|
|
Demoknight
Posting Freak
Posts: 1150
Registered: 7-6-2013
Location: Atlanta, GA
Member Is Offline
Mood: ADIDAK
|
|
The last time I rode my buggy on my local beach, I noticed MAJOR speed bouncing around 20-25 mph on one of my rear tires. I am using extra wides on
standard PL plastic wheels. I think I had some mud or sand stuck somewhere on the wheel or one of my bearings had seized and was causing the wobbles.
It was absolutely keeping me from going any faster, and rattling the fillings out of my mouth at the same time. If your tires are imbalanced enough
for you to feel it, you are definitely losing speed and causing extra wear. No question about it.
NAPKA US8008
Kites:
Ozone R1 V3 7m
Flysurfer Sonic v3 15m
Flysurfer Speed 3 Deluxe 19m
Peter Lynn Charger 2 12m
Ozone Access Reride 6m
Peter Lynn 2013 Reactor 5.5m
Peter Lynn 2013 Reactor 8.6m
Prism Tensor 5.0m
Ride:
GT-Race Code:R6
Weird Beard VTT Custom
|
|
Snake
Member
Posts: 480
Registered: 5-7-2012
Location: Midwest
Member Is Offline
Mood: Boost to the moon
|
|
All of my mountain board wheels are un-balanced because of the valve stem. I wonder is balancing them would do anything?
Arcs - Charger I 8m, 10m, 12m, Venom I 13m - F-Arc 1200, 1600
Single Skin - Born-Kite LongStar2
Fixed Bridles - Pansh Legend 4.5m - Peter Lynn Voltage 3m
|
|
abkayak
Posting Freak
Posts: 2272
Registered: 7-1-2012
Location: a.b. NY
Member Is Offline
Mood: loving life and becoming wise in simplicity
|
|
pretty sure thats going to the extreme..may be possible but cant be worth the effort
US-31...Cquad set/ 2.5 Bullet/ 2.6 Viper/ 2.9m Reactor/ 2- 3.5m Bullet/ 3.6 Beamer/ 4m Buster/ 4m Toxic/ 4m Ikon dp/ 4.5 Bullet/ 4.9m Blade/ 5.6
Twister/ 6.6m Blade/ 7.5 Apex/ 9m Fuel/ Phantom I 9,12,15,18/ 2 Flexibugs/ PL Big Foot/ landboards
|
|
BeamerBob
Posting Freak
Posts: 8308
Registered: 11-5-2007
Location: Down on the bayou
Member Is Offline
|
|
The impact of balanced or not is magnified or trivialized by the weight and diameter of the tire. ATB tires are so short, it would be hard to notice
an out of balance wheel unless you artificially made it unbalanced. Then you would need sufficient speed to notice.
The only time I've had any wobbles on my Landsegler wheels (which are slightly out of balance due to the valve stem) seem to be due to harmonic
interaction with the lakebed surface. Sometimes it seems like the speed and surface match up and will cause a wobble in the front wheel. If the
surface changes, the wobble goes away. Talking about this does have me thinking about using some sort of weight to counterbalance the valve stem to
have the wheels more balanced. The magnets used on bike computers might be just the ticket since they mount on the spokes and would be adjustable.
Coastal Wind Sports Team Rider
Landsegler Disc wheels
PTW Hero Buggy - XXtreme ApeXX Buggy US 88 - Libre Hardcore
IvanpahBuggyExpo.com
Youtube link
Bob Muse
HQ Montana X 8m, Montana IX 12m, HQ Ignition LEI 5m,
PL Phantom 12m, 15m, Big Blu 24m+, Synergy 10m, Venom 10m, 13m , Phantom II 12m Vapors 3.8, 5.4, Crosskite Sonic 7m, PKD Combat 10.3m
Uturn Butane 2.5m PKD Buster 3m Genetrix Hydra 7m Ozone Yakuza GT 14m
|
|
RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
Quote: Originally posted by Snake | All of my mountain board wheels are un-balanced because of the valve stem. I wonder is balancing them would do anything? |
I'd imagine that the effect might be too slight for you to notice due to the small rotating mass but I could be completely wrong.
The mass maybe small but the rotation speeds are greater than my ATV wheels given the same speed and far greater than discs. In fact balancing ATB
rims might produce the most beneficial results as a consequence. I'd give it a go. I'm sure you'd be the first person to try and balance ATB wheels
and I'd be interested to hear the results.
|
|
RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
Quote: Originally posted by BeamerBob | The impact of balanced or not is magnified or trivialized by the weight and diameter of the tire. ATB tires are so short, it would be hard to notice
an out of balance wheel unless you artificially made it unbalanced. Then you would need sufficient speed to notice.
The only time I've had any wobbles on my Landsegler wheels (which are slightly out of balance due to the valve stem) seem to be due to harmonic
interaction with the lakebed surface. Sometimes it seems like the speed and surface match up and will cause a wobble in the front wheel. If the
surface changes, the wobble goes away. Talking about this does have me thinking about using some sort of weight to counterbalance the valve stem to
have the wheels more balanced. The magnets used on bike computers might be just the ticket since they mount on the spokes and would be adjustable.
|
Give it a go. I'm keen to hear your findings on this.
|
|
PHREERIDER
Posting Freak
Posts: 5781
Registered: 13-2-2008
Location: SC
Member Is Offline
Mood: chilled....but ready to SAIL!
|
|
on speed runs with haize flexboardz tire growth with 9"wheels in 50 mph + has been an issue ....they seem well balanced but any faster really demands
ultra precision hardware , the stock soft tires are grippy but produce a vague feel of control at hi speeds... have to have moto for sure . 8"
crossairs GI vibrate like hell around 25-30.
in regular riding a balanced tire has no advantage of merit...speed is a different story fo sho!
|
|
apextech
Member
Posts: 262
Registered: 27-9-2010
Location: Monterey, Ca.
Member Is Offline
Mood: Often Edgy
|
|
Man, am I envious of your tires, no such item avialable here in the U.S.
HQ Apex ll 5.0m
HQ Apex ll 7.5m
HQ Apex ll 10.0m
|
|
RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
Quote: Originally posted by PHREERIDER | on speed runs with haize flexboardz tire growth with 9"wheels in 50 mph + has been an issue ....they seem well balanced but any faster really demands
ultra precision hardware , the stock soft tires are grippy but produce a vague feel of control at hi speeds... have to have moto for sure . 8"
crossairs GI vibrate like hell around 25-30.
in regular riding a balanced tire has no advantage of merit...speed is a different story fo sho! |
Yeah, I'm sure where speed is concerned that's where the difference will be felt, even the slightest offset in balance will become exaggerated the
faster the wheel spins.
|
|
RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
No Beach Racers available in the US ? I had no idea.
|
|
BeamerBob
Posting Freak
Posts: 8308
Registered: 11-5-2007
Location: Down on the bayou
Member Is Offline
|
|
Any PL dealer can order them.
Coastal Wind Sports Team Rider
Landsegler Disc wheels
PTW Hero Buggy - XXtreme ApeXX Buggy US 88 - Libre Hardcore
IvanpahBuggyExpo.com
Youtube link
Bob Muse
HQ Montana X 8m, Montana IX 12m, HQ Ignition LEI 5m,
PL Phantom 12m, 15m, Big Blu 24m+, Synergy 10m, Venom 10m, 13m , Phantom II 12m Vapors 3.8, 5.4, Crosskite Sonic 7m, PKD Combat 10.3m
Uturn Butane 2.5m PKD Buster 3m Genetrix Hydra 7m Ozone Yakuza GT 14m
|
|
jellis
Senior Member
Posts: 845
Registered: 5-1-2004
Location: Sunset Beach
Member Is Offline
Mood: SOBB
|
|
Has anyone used Dynabeads? I have used them for years to balance my buggy tires. No more stick on weights required. Just removed the valve in the tire
stem, use the clear tube with the beads inside, slip it over the valve stem, pinch off the clear tube at measure intervals, then pour them in, install
the valve in the stem and inflate your tire. If the tire is not deformed they will balance Bigfoot, small tires and motorcycle type tires.
LifeTechnologies has the Dynobeads.
Sorry for the rambling as pain meds are helping until Monday.
Jon Ellis US08
|
|
BeamerBob
Posting Freak
Posts: 8308
Registered: 11-5-2007
Location: Down on the bayou
Member Is Offline
|
|
Jon you are coming through loud and clear. I've got to order some of
those. Any recommendations on which configuration to order? Can I get a 3 oz bag and split it between 3 tires? Do we need an applicator? Do we
need filtered valve stems?
Coastal Wind Sports Team Rider
Landsegler Disc wheels
PTW Hero Buggy - XXtreme ApeXX Buggy US 88 - Libre Hardcore
IvanpahBuggyExpo.com
Youtube link
Bob Muse
HQ Montana X 8m, Montana IX 12m, HQ Ignition LEI 5m,
PL Phantom 12m, 15m, Big Blu 24m+, Synergy 10m, Venom 10m, 13m , Phantom II 12m Vapors 3.8, 5.4, Crosskite Sonic 7m, PKD Combat 10.3m
Uturn Butane 2.5m PKD Buster 3m Genetrix Hydra 7m Ozone Yakuza GT 14m
|
|
jellis
Senior Member
Posts: 845
Registered: 5-1-2004
Location: Sunset Beach
Member Is Offline
Mood: SOBB
|
|
Bob I usually use 1 1/2 oz for bigfoots, and 1 oz for the smaller Carlyle slicks. I am looking for the tall tire setup now, but it seems motorcycle
tire suggestions are up to 2 oz. Amazon seems to have a deal!
Sorry about the high jacking your thread RedSky, nice looking rims!
Jon Ellis US08
|
|
BeamerBob
Posting Freak
Posts: 8308
Registered: 11-5-2007
Location: Down on the bayou
Member Is Offline
|
|
I think it's a good development of the thread. This seems like the perfect solution.
Coastal Wind Sports Team Rider
Landsegler Disc wheels
PTW Hero Buggy - XXtreme ApeXX Buggy US 88 - Libre Hardcore
IvanpahBuggyExpo.com
Youtube link
Bob Muse
HQ Montana X 8m, Montana IX 12m, HQ Ignition LEI 5m,
PL Phantom 12m, 15m, Big Blu 24m+, Synergy 10m, Venom 10m, 13m , Phantom II 12m Vapors 3.8, 5.4, Crosskite Sonic 7m, PKD Combat 10.3m
Uturn Butane 2.5m PKD Buster 3m Genetrix Hydra 7m Ozone Yakuza GT 14m
|
|
RedSky
Posting Freak
Posts: 1751
Registered: 7-9-2009
Member Is Offline
|
|
Quote: Originally posted by jellis | Bob I usually use 1 1/2 oz for bigfoots, and 1 oz for the smaller Carlyle slicks. I am looking for the tall tire setup now, but it seems motorcycle
tire suggestions are up to 2 oz. Amazon seems to have a deal!
Sorry about the high jacking your thread RedSky, nice looking rims! |
Nah man, its all relevant. My threads normally get just a few posts anyway. Glad to have sparked some interest at last.
Your Dynabeads solution is interesting. Makes my weights kinda obsolete, so simple and easy I wish I knew about them earlier.
I finally finished off my wheels on Saturday. The Beach Racers were out of balance 80-90g but shockingly the thinner eurotrax bigfoot up front was out
by 220g :o
I'm sure at the very least the buggy mounted GoPro should experience less vibration now.
|
|